Struesdell's Tier Lists [10/4/12]

I kn ow this might sound like a silly question, but is there a way to keep the comments on each card somewhere? I'm sure some people would like to read comments on cards that are older and more affordable as well as the new cards that come out. Just a thought, keep up the great work

Like a comparative evaluation of each unit? That'd be a very interesting read for those of us who are newer :O

My opinion for 5* Tier 1
Heidi=Joa > Edgar=Laura > Sheryl=Vic=Erhard >=? Meg=Rose=Sofia

Quote :

Laura straddles the line between tier 1 and tier 2. Her stats are pretty good, but she's a magic slow type unit -- we've all seen that before.
Sonia is interesting -- a C speed melee that can hit air, and has area attack. Her stats are not the most impressive, and she's probably going to be really common, so if we were doing this by rarity she'd lose points for that. That said, she's certainly a bit unique in her type/skill composition!

more like with this stuff here. as soon as newer cards come out, all of these types of comments in the list go away.

alucard35o wrote:

Quote :

Laura straddles the line between tier 1 and tier 2. Her stats are pretty good, but she's a magic slow type unit -- we've all seen that before.
Sonia is interesting -- a C speed melee that can hit air, and has area attack. Her stats are not the most impressive, and she's probably going to be really common, so if we were doing this by rarity she'd lose points for that. That said, she's certainly a bit unique in her type/skill composition!

more like with this stuff here. as soon as newer cards come out, all of these types of comments in the list go away.

thats why the list needs constant updates

Constant updates how, do you think?

I only put information on new cards because people are typically aware of where the old cards fall, and if people have a question here they can ask. That and there's usually a few weeks between the next tierlist with new cards comes out anyway.

That said, people can write up why they think certain cards are good to get if they feel like it, and I might work on that later. (:

But some may just write it up because they have it or because they want to sell it.

That's why this is a forum, you can debate whether or not their logic is valid.

I find this tier system to be dull
and useless ikno its only a opinion but too many people's refer to this
List as if it was the official system its becoming. Redicious , -_- just letting my thoughts out about it I'm not trying to offend anyone by this

Everyone is free to their own opinion.

But I will keep reiterating:

1) This is not a price guide. People can use it (and their own deductions) to decide what they want to price at, but on its own it is just an opinion on how useful certain units are compared to others.
2) If you have a criticism or question about the list, feel free to post here. However, do note that a lot of effort went into making it, and saying "I don't think it should be this way!" while not actually putting forth any of your own evidence or modeling is.... a bit silly.

I'll make a new thread with updated information when the new event comes out. I'll try to explain what went into making it and look at some units and why they are top tier. Anyone who wants to make their own tierlist based on other factors should feel free to -- or if anyone has a suggestion how units should be sorted, I can look at it too.

I think we should just do what we talked about clocks. And you know what my suggestion was in regards to this thread.

Open statement, not singling anyone out:

If you don't like the list, make your own, and describe why cards are where they are on yours.

If you have an argument for revision of this list or someone's placement on it, speak up.

If you just don't like tier lists in general, feel free to ignore this one.

Nothing here is carved in stone and handed down by mysterious flying druids.